5 Ways to Win Your Candidate During the Offer

5 Ways to Win Your Candidate During the Offer

You’ve conducted the initial executive search and several rounds of interviews; now you’ve found THE candidate who will bring that edge you’ve been looking for to your organization. Your work is over, right? Not quite.


Hiring managers often make the mistake of thinking the work is finished after they have made the offer, but maintaining focus and staying engaged in the final moments of the recruiting process are critical to securing a candidate.


You may be tempted to assume candidates are interested because they remained in the recruiting process. After narrowing the pool down to one choice, though, the decision to accept now lies in the hands of the candidate. With the finish line in sight, your organization must see the recruiting process through to receive a “Yes” from the other side of the table.


Today on The Water Cooler, we discuss 5 ways to ensure that you come out on the winning end when making an offer to a candidate.


Ask the Right Questions


To win your candidate, you must first master your phrasing. Instead of asking if a candidate wants the offer, ask if they want the job.


Every candidate wants an offer; receiving it makes them feel wanted and like they “won” the recruiting process. What hiring managers do not want, though, is to extend an offer that will be rejected.


Asking the candidate if they want the job can help you avoid delivering an offer that will be turned down. You may learn that, while the candidate is interested, they still have questions about the opportunity. Allowing them the chance to complete their own vetting process leads to more informed decision making and a higher likelihood that they will accept. Moreover, once the candidate has finished their own evaluation process and communicated that they want the position, you can decide how to craft the offer.


Find Out What Matters


From vacation time and healthcare to equity and retirement plans, candidates place different priorities on different offer components. Understanding what matters most to the candidate is critical in making a successful offer.


For example, when relocating candidates, covering or subsidizing one-time moving costs speaks volumes to them and their families. Spouses/significant others, children and other family members will be equally impacted by relocation, and their opinions may influence a candidate’s final decision. Making the gesture to assist with the move can garner buy-in from everyone involved, including the candidate, and lead to an accepted offer.


Get Creative


Creativity with compensation, benefits and other offer components can play a crucial role in ensuring a “Yes” from your candidate. Unable to raise the base salary for the position? Try including a signing bonus or adding additional vacation time to increase compensation. Providing equity, long-term incentive plans (LTIPs) or accelerated vesting can also help sweeten the deal for a candidate.


Outside of competitive compensation, companies may also offer car allowances, monthly parking, flexible work hours or the opportunity to work remotely in order to attract candidates. No matter what benefits you choose to provide, make sure that you continue to think about what matters most to your candidate.


Make It Personal


No one likes the generic “Dear Candidate…” email. Both your organization and the candidate invest time and resources into the process, so see the effort through by making your offer over the phone or in person.


Verbally extending an offer also doubles as a safeguard to rejection. Directly talking with candidates provides them the opportunity to ask any final questions they may have about the role, as well as presents the opportunity for them to accept before you initiate the necessary paperwork.


You should also allow a candidate adequate time to think over and respond to an offer. Delivering an offer on a Friday is advantageous. Your organization won’t lose any working days while the candidate considers the offer, and the candidate has a chance to unplug, process and discuss with other potential decision influencers before accepting.


Put Your Best Foot Forward


With a solid understanding of your candidate’s needs and goals, you can craft an offer letter that will be accepted outright, rather than entering into a negotiation.


Putting your best offer forward indicates that there is less to negotiate and signals how the candidate will be treated in the future at your organization – like their needs are being met versus being “nickel and dimed” each year with raises and bonuses.


Recruiting firms provide a major advantage in this final step; as third party providers, we are able to prompt candidates to disclose their true financial/benefits figures to understand what the best offer should look like and ultimately bring both sides of the table together.


Making an offer is a big step for both your company and the candidate. Completing the entire recruiting process is key to not only winning the candidate but also setting your organization up for success to retain top talent.


Want more insight? Check out our latest article Philosophy, Data and Structure; A Simple Guide to Executive Compensation or contact us to discuss your hiring needs for your next critical role.


By Greg Togni May 2, 2025
In the 2025 NFL Draft, Shedeur Sanders, once projected as a top five pick, experienced a surprising fall to the fifth round before being selected by the Cleveland Browns. This unexpected drop raised questions about his draft stock and the factors influencing team decisions. Despite his impressive college career, including setting school records and other accolades, Sanders' draft experience underscores a crucial lesson for companies: hiring decisions are multifaceted and not solely based on past performance or potential. Just as NFL teams must consider various factors beyond a player's statistics, businesses should adopt a comprehensive approach to hiring, evaluating candidates holistically to ensure the best fit for their organization's needs. While the NFL Draft might just look like a televised event where young athletes get picked by professional teams, beneath the fanfare is a highly strategic, data-driven process that offers invaluable insights into one of the most important business practices: hiring . If you're in the corporate world and responsible for recruiting talent—whether you're a founder, HR executive, or team leader, there's a lot you can learn from how NFL teams approach drafting. Let’s explore how this intense, high-stakes selection process mirrors and can elevate traditional corporate hiring. Understand What You’re Hiring For The first step in great hiring is clarity. In one NFL team, draft results consistently lagged for one side of the ball. A simple survey revealed why: there was zero consensus among scouts and coaches about what success looked like at a key position. Without a shared vision, decisions were scattershot. In business , the same thing happens. Teams rush to hire without aligning on goals. Do you need a disruptive innovator or a steady team player? A generalist or a deep specialist? Skipping this conversation sets you up to fail. Tip : Clearly define roles with specific traits, values, and performance goals before interviewing even begins. Structure Beats Technology Despite all the tech, there’s no magical algorithm that guarantees a good draft pick. What separates the top NFL teams is process , consistent, disciplined evaluation systems. The same principle holds true in business. Unstructured hiring decisions are noisy and prone to bias. Managers get influenced by irrelevant factors: a great handshake, a shared alma mater, or how the last interview went. Consistency comes from structured scorecards, checklists, and predefined evaluation criteria. Tip : Use structured interviews and weighted scorecards to keep evaluations focused and replicable. Keep Evaluators Independent One underrated tactic NFL teams use: separating scout opinions. Some teams purposely blind scouts to each other's evaluations to preserve independent judgment. That’s critical, because once someone hears a strong opinion, they’re prone to “anchor” on it, consciously or not. In corporate hiring , it’s the same story. If the first interviewer gushes about a candidate, others may unconsciously lower their guard. True diversity of opinion only exists if assessments are made independently. Tip : Have team members submit their evaluations separately before group discussions. Interviewing is Like the Combine – But Not Everything The NFL Combine is a week-long showcase where draft prospects go through physical and mental tests. But teams don’t draft solely based on who runs the fastest 40-yard dash. They look at long-term potential, game tape, and coachability . In companies , i nterviews are important, but they’re just one part of a broader evaluation. Candidates may be nervous, overly rehearsed, or misrepresent their skills. Supplement interviews with trial projects, references, and past performance reviews. Tip : Give candidates real-world problems to solve that mimic the work they’ll be doing. Fit Over Flash Some of the NFL’s biggest draft busts were players with jaw-dropping athleticism who simply didn’t fit into the team’s system. Conversely, many late-round picks became legends because they were a great fit for a team's specific needs and culture. In business , skills can be taught, but cultural fit, adaptability, and motivation are harder to instill. Ask: Will this person thrive in our environment? Will they complement our team dynamics? Tip : Ask culture-focused questions and involve future teammates in the interview to assess chemistry. Break Candidates into Components NFL teams don’t evaluate a player as just “good” or “bad.” They break skills down: footwork, decision-making, toughness, coachability. Then they score each attribute separately. In hiring , we often rely on vague impressions. But global ratings are prone to bias and inconsistency across interviewers. Instead, decompose the job into core competencies—communication, technical ability, leadership, and score each explicitly. Tip : Break job performance into 4–6 distinct traits and rate each on a consistent scale. Rebuild the Full Picture- Mechanically After breaking down a candidate’s attributes, NFL teams reassemble their evaluations into an overall rating. Some simply average scores across scouts. It might sound simplistic—but it’s surprisingly effective. In companies , intuitive judgment often dominates. The loudest voice or most senior person can sway the group. Instead, use aggregated, weighted scores as a starting point. It creates a more objective, repeatable process. Tip : Let the data guide your shortlist, then use discussion to refine (not override) decisions. Data-Informed Decisions Are Key NFL franchises now use advanced analytics to measure player performance in ways the eye test alone can’t. From GPS tracking of player speed to AI-assisted video analysis, decision-makers are armed with data. Lesson for companies : Go beyond gut feelings and use structured hiring practices . Utilize assessment tools, skill tests, and personality inventories. Tip : Implement scorecards during interviews and pre-hire assessments for objectivity. High Draft Pick ≠ Guaranteed Success Tom Brady was a sixth-round pick. Kurt Warner went undrafted. Meanwhile, many five-star athletes flamed out. The lesson? Success isn’t always visible on a resume. In hiring , don’t over-rely on pedigree. Grit, curiosity, and coachability are better predictors of future success than past prestige. Tip : Ask candidates about setbacks, learning moments, and how they seek feedback. Final Whistle There is no silver bullet for hiring- no AI tool, test, or gut instinct that will always get it right. But there is a better way: a repeatable, structured, thoughtful process . The NFL Draft, for all its hype, works because the best teams stick to principles: define goals, evaluate consistently, prioritize fit, and learn over time. These same principles can help any organization—from startups to Fortune 500s—build stronger teams and better futures. So next April, when the draft rolls around, don’t just watch for your favorite team’s pick. Take notes. Because if you want to win the talent game, the playbook is already out there.
By Greg Togni May 1, 2025
Chief Financial Officer ABOUT THE COMPANY Founded in 1947, Oregon Tool, Inc. has grown from a basement in Portland, Oregon, to a global designer, manufacturer, and marketer of precision cutting tools, equipment, and accessories for consumers and professionals in more than 110 countries with 3200 team members. Building off the pioneering spirit of its founder, Joseph Buford Cox, Oregon Tool has transformed the cutting industry and have become the world’s #1 manufacturer of saw chain and guide bars for chainsaws and diamond saw chain for concrete and pipe, a leading manufacturer of agricultural tractor attachments, and the leading OEM supplier of first-fit and replacement parts. Its products are sold into the aftermarket through multiple channels, including distributors, dealers, mass merchants and e-commerce, as well as to original equipment manufacturers for “first fit” use on new equipment. Since its founding in the 1940s, Oregon Tool has grown from a family business into a multinational organization. Oregon Tool is owned by Platinum Equity, a global investment firm with more than $48 billion of assets under management and a portfolio of approximately 60 operating companies that serve customers around the world. Platinum Equity specializes in mergers, acquisitions and operations – a trademarked strategy it calls M&A&O® – acquiring and operating companies in a broad range of business markets, including manufacturing, distribution, transportation and logistics, equipment rental, metals services, media and entertainment, technology, telecommunications and other industries. Over the past 29 years Platinum Equity has completed more than 450 acquisitions. POSITION SUMMARY Based on a recent promotion of Oregon Tool’s Chief Financial Officer to Chief Executive Officer , Oregon Tool is seeking an experienced Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to lead all financial functions across our U.S. and international operations with a team of over 140 members. The CFO will be a key strategic partner to the executive leadership team, playing a pivotal role in shaping the company’s growth strategy, ensuring financial performance, managing risk, and overseeing the IT function. As the financial steward of a private equity-backed global organization, the CFO will manage financial operations, optimize cash flow, oversee budgeting and forecasting, and support operational efficiency. The CFO will also be responsible for aligning the finance and IT teams with the strategic vision set by the private equity owners, helping to drive value creation, cost optimization, and scalability. KEY RESPONSIBILITIES Strategic Financial Leadership: Develop and execute the financial strategy to support both short-term and long-term growth objectives, aligning with the playbook. Drive strategic financial planning, providing insights on capital structure, liquidity, and funding strategies. Partner with the executive leadership team to guide business performance, identify operational efficiencies, and drive margin improvements. Support the execution of an exit strategy or liquidity event, working closely with the private equity firm to align with investment objectives. Financial Operations & Reporting: Oversee the preparation of financial statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP and international standards, ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements across all jurisdictions. Lead monthly, quarterly, and annual financial reporting to the private equity firm, board of directors, and other key stakeholders. Implement best practices for financial reporting and performance analysis, ensuring the company maintains a strong financial position. Direct the finance team in all areas of financial operations, including accounting, financial reporting, budgeting, and tax compliance. Cash Flow & Risk Management: Manage the company’s cash flow, working capital, and liquidity to ensure the business operates efficiently and remains financially stable. Develop and implement risk management strategies, overseeing financial controls, insurance, and mitigation of operational, financial, and market risks. Work with external auditors, legal advisors, and tax consultants to manage risk and optimize the tax structure across global operations. This includes cyber security and IT Risk Management. Mergers & Acquisitions (M&A) and Capital Strategy: Lead or support M&A initiatives, including target identification, due diligence, valuation, and integration, to support the company’s growth strategy and value creation. Partner with the private equity firm to evaluate and execute on new investment opportunities, optimizing capital structure and aligning with the firm’s strategic priorities. Global Operations & International Oversight: Oversee financial operations in all international locations, ensuring compliance with local financial regulations and tax laws. Maximize financial processes and reporting systems across geographies, driving operational efficiencies and consistent decision-making globally. Coordinate with international finance teams to ensure alignment with overall company financial objectives and adherence to best practices. IT Strategy & Oversight: Lead the IT function, aligning technology investments with financial goals and operational needs. Ensure systems are scalable, secure, and enable financial reporting and forecasting capabilities. Partner with the IT team to ensure the integration of financial systems (e.g., ERP, cloud services) to enhance reporting accuracy and streamline operations. Drive initiatives that optimize the company’s technological infrastructure, ensuring it supports both financial and operational goals, particularly in the context of global manufacturing and sales. Leadership & Team Development: Build and lead a high-performance finance team, providing mentorship and fostering professional growth opportunities. Develop strong relationships with cross-functional teams to ensure finance is closely integrated with all business operations. Collaborate with the leadership team to set the overall direction for the business, ensuring that financial goals are met and exceeded. ESSENTIAL DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES Financial Reporting Oversee the preparation and accuracy of consolidated financial statements in compliance with U.S. GAAP, IFRS, and other relevant international accounting standards. Ensure timely and accurate monthly, quarterly, and annual financial reporting for internal and external stakeholders. Manage the preparation and production of consolidated financial reports adhering to internal reporting deadlines. Interface with external auditors on the timing and coordination of the year-end audit and work closely with them throughout their audit cycle. Develop and communicate the reporting schedule internally to Oregon Tool locations and facilitate compliance with reporting deadlines. Streamline and provide continual improvements to the master closing package template utilized by all reporting units. Lead and manage the external reporting cycles in an accurate and timely manner to achieve compliance with debt covenants and reporting deadlines including preparation of financial statements and footnotes. Ensure that the reporting system is able to produce financial information in the format and configuration required by senior management. Accounting Operations Lead the North America accounting team, ensuring accurate and efficient day-to-day accounting operations. Oversee the monthly and year-end close processes, ensuring timely reconciliations, accurate journal entries, and adherence to closing schedules. Ensure compliance with internal controls, policies, and procedures to safeguard company assets. Maintain and monitor an effective system of internal accounting and financial reporting controls. Interpret and analyze and report on periodic results. Maintain an internal performance management reporting system. Provide accounting direction and support to company-wide reporting units. Manage the collection and consolidation of data from company-wide reporting units. Supervise the general ledger for various accounts and legal entities, ensuring the accounting records are accurate and well documented. Lead continuous improvement efforts to improve processes and shorten reporting cycle times. Maintain, update and improve policies, processes, and systems including automation of key activities. Team Management Lead, mentor, and develop the management teams across CP, Mold, and PD, ensuring accountability and high performance. Establish clear performance metrics and KPIs for all areas of the business to drive results and enhance team collaboration. Maintain good communication, promote problem-solving, assign responsibilities, and provide training and mentoring to employees. Select and develop key operational executives and successors, assign accountabilities, set objectives, and establish priorities. Team Leadership and Development Lead, mentor, and develop a high-performing accounting team. Foster a culture of continuous improvement, promoting efficiency, accuracy, and best practices. Manage performance, establish clear development goals, and provide ongoing coaching for team members. Lead documentation and continual improvement of departmental work processes. QUALIFCATIONS • Minimum of 5-7+ years of experience in executive financial leadership positions, with a focus on manufacturing, sales, and international operations. • Prior experience in a private equity-backed company is highly preferred, with a proven track record of driving growth and value creation. • Strong experience in M&A, capital structure optimization, and working closely with private equity investors. • Experience in capital markets managing banking and investor relations. • Strong financial modeling, analysis, and business forecasting skills. • Expertise in U.S. GAAP, IFRS, international financial regulations, and tax compliance across multiple jurisdictions. • Experience in IT or Business Analyst management, optimizing global systems, ERP software, and other integrated technologies. • Excellent leadership skills, with the ability to motivate and develop high-performing teams in a fast-paced, growth-oriented environment. • Ability to communicate complex financial concepts clearly to both financial and non-financial stakeholders, including the private equity investors. LEADERSHIP COMPETENCIES Strategic Orientation & Commercial Acumen The ideal candidate will have a strategic mindset and will look at business challenges and opportunities in a holistic way. With that strategic mindset, executing on the existing Playbook is the priority. They will understand how to integrate market and competitive trends, organizational state, and other issues into a coherent vision for change and growth and link this vision into a series of initiatives and priorities that are compelling and logical. They will have a strong track record of driving growth and value through internal initiatives. Execution / Results Orientation The ideal candidate will have a demonstrated track record of delivering impact in the business. The individual must have a high sense of urgency, be a highly driven execution- oriented leader who has repeatedly led organizations through rapid transformation that yield increased levels of growth and sustainable performance. They will have the ability and determination to move a portfolio of strategic imperatives forward, using performance metrics and benchmarks to track progress. Team Leadership / Talent Development The candidate will build deep organization strength, inspire and motivate the entire organization to impact the future growth, continuity and profitability of the business. They should be focused on coaching, mentoring and testing their senior leadership team to ensure continued growth and success of the business. The leader will consistently be recruiting to benchmark their existing team and as needed, bring in best-in-class performers. The ideal candidate will possess the ability to effectively motivate others to achieve goals and objectives as they build the next level leadership talent. Collaboration, Communication & Influencing The leader will be a good listener with outstanding interpersonal qualities and a natural, effective consultative style. They will have demonstrated the ability to be straightforward, frank, and direct with others while communicating respect. They must be able to influence, collaborate and partner with the different entities to drive improvements. This includes the ability to work effectively with a virtual, geographically dispersed organization. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been engaged by Oregon Tool to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Matt Oltmann /971.235.6236/ matt.oltmann@180one.com .
By Greg Togni April 23, 2025
180one is pleased to announce our recent partnership with Pike Street Capital and the successful placement of a new Board Member for Superior Duct Fabrication, a Pike Street portfolio company! Superior Duct Fabrication is a leading provider of commercial and industrial HVAC duct systems, known for its high-quality fabrication, reliability, and customer service. The company serves a wide range of industries, delivering complex ductwork solutions with precision and speed. Pike Street Capital, a Seattle-based private equity firm focused on industrial growth companies, acquired Superior Duct Fabrication as part of its strategy to invest in scalable, high-performing manufacturing businesses. Pike Street partners with management teams to accelerate growth and build long-term value through operational improvements and strategic leadership. As part of this effort, Pike Street Capital partnered with 180one to recruit a new board member to help guide Superior Duct’s continued expansion and success. Congratulations to Pike Street Capital, Superior Duct Fabrication, and the 180one Search Team on a successful board placement!
More Posts