How Benchmarking Could Ultimately Cost You the Perfect Candidate

Have you ever bought a house? How was that decision made? Like most homebuyers, you probably determined the neighborhood, number of bedrooms and bathrooms needed, as well as other important criteria before you started the house-hunting process. The next step would be talking to a real estate agent and giving them all of those well thought-out criteria, in hopes that they can eventually track down a house that fits each need. This process can take a long time, sometimes dragging on for months, but this does not always have to be the case.


With your pre-planning and knowing your criteria, you might find that the first house your realtor shows you meets or possibly exceeds all of your expectations. What next? In this competitive housing market, where most people can be on the hunt for months or even years, the next step should be around making an offer immediately. Those buyers who have established their criteria, make the offer, but those who have not will typically hesitate and want to see another house for comparative purpose.

Row of houses

Here arises the issue of benchmarking—of waiting for a chance to have a side by side comparison in order to feel comfortable moving forward. The constant need to weigh what is available and right in front of you with what could potentially be better ends up holding up the process and oftentimes contributing to a loss. In a competitive housing market, you need to be in a position to confidently move forward in the buying process, and this is where planning helps. For those who hesitate, the house in question is already under contract by the time they are ready—probably with the buyer who knew what they were looking for in a home.


What is the lesson here?

Know what you’re looking for, and fight the urge to compare something great to whatever else could be out there. Fight the urge to benchmark. The perfect house was in plain sight, but then it was gone, all because of lack of planning, hesitation or the need to benchmark.


The hiring process is actually quite similar to that of purchasing a house. Before the interviewing process begins, the hiring manager devises a similar list of criteria to that of the home-buyer. This is typically presented in the form of a job description, which will include everything that the perfect candidate will possess.


At 180one, we use a best practice of developing a “Candidate Success Profile” as a way to both determine what attributes the ideal candidate will possess, and as a way to help evaluate candidates against these attributes. As potential candidates are evaluated against the Candidate Success Profile, the decision making process of whom to hire should be more clear.

Multiple candidates

Similar to the home-buyer, when a hiring manager is conducting a search, they tend to be more comfortable when there are a few options in front of them and there is an opportunity to interview multiple candidates. A problem seems to arise when the perfect candidate is the first one to walk through the door. This person might check every single box on the list of criteria, but it becomes difficult to make a decision without going through the steps of finishing the process. In the meantime, that perfect candidate could be getting the message that there is hesitation, and that perhaps something is wrong, potentially causing them to back out. In reality, the hiring manager is merely displaying a confirmation bias by needing to benchmark as a way to confirm that the right person has already been found.


A candidate is either a fit, or not, and a hiring manager can usually figure that out pretty early in the process. That being said, if they are feeling lukewarm about a candidate, that candidate is likely not the right choice, and therefore the hiring manager is better off passing on said candidate and continuing the search. On the flip-side, if it is clear that a candidate perfectly fits the sought-after profile, no time should be wasted by curiosity of whom else could possibly surface should the search continue.


Don’t Miss Out by Not Being Prepared

If criteria are set in place, and a candidate meets all of those criteria, why waste the time and resources continuing with the interview process? Why risk sending the wrong message to a potential new employee? Part of why it is a good idea to prepare a Candidate Success Profile is because of the value and importance of pre-work. It ultimately saves time and helps eliminate that hesitation that can be felt when the right candidate is suddenly presented. In another article on our Water Cooler, we break down ways to create a more effective hiring process. It is possible to be set up for success and prepared for when that perfect candidate is identified. 


The goal here is to help make the decision making process more comfortable. It is in human nature to act impulsively as opposed to logically, and therefore it is entirely understandable that a hiring manager would take precautions to avoid acting on impulse. But the simple way to avoid making an impulsive decision is by creating that list of criteria first. When there is a goal in place and an ideal candidate profile to fill, it will not be impulsive if and when the hiring process is completed faster than expected for the right candidate.



It is easy to be set up for success in the hiring process when the proper preparation is done ahead of time. Whether a Candidate Success Profile such as ours is used, or a similar method of organizing and determining criteria is developed, hiring managers can make sure to be ready to hire as soon as the right person comes along. Make that list of criteria and stick with it. If a candidate matches, it’s a go; if a candidate doesn’t match, it’s a no. There is no need to benchmark.

By Effie Zimmerman December 23, 2025
Chief Financial Officer ABOUT THE COMPANY Superior Duct Fabrication is a market-leading fabricator of highly technical commercial ducting and specialty HVAC products, serving mission-critical end markets such as data centers, semiconductor manufacturing, healthcare, higher education, and industrial facilities. Founded in 2002 and headquartered in Pomona, CA, Superior operates out of five strategic manufacturing sites across the Western U.S. and Ohio, with a deeply experienced union workforce, vertically integrated operations, and a reputation for quality, speed, and reliability. In 2025, Seattle-based private equity firm Pike Street Capital made a platform investment in Superior to accelerate growth through geographic expansion, product innovation, and targeted acquisitions. With a strong leadership team, trusted customer relationships, and increasing demand for sophisticated air handling solutions, Superior is positioned for rapid, scalable growth. THE ROLE Superior is seeking an experienced and results-driven Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to lead the financial strategy and execution of its private equity-backed, high-growth business. The CFO will play a critical role in enabling both organic and acquisitive growth, optimizing operations, and driving value creation in partnership with the CEO, President, and private equity sponsor. This is a hands-on executive leadership role ideal for a proven financial leader with deep manufacturing expertise and a track record of operating in dynamic, performance-driven environments. RESPONSIBILITIES Executive & Strategic Leadership Serve as a strategic partner to the CEO and executive team, actively contributing to policy, direction, and long-term planning. Help define and execute the company’s growth strategy in alignment with operational, financial, and market objectives. Drive a high-performance culture through accountability, transparency, and collaboration. Lead by example, setting the tone and culture across the organization. Operate as a player/coach—comfortable building models, developing presentations, and engaging directly in critical business issues. Attract, develop, and retain top-tier financial and operational talent. Lead major business initiatives and projects (e.g., productivity improvement, pricing strategies) with measurable results. Shoulder broad business leadership responsibility, beyond traditional finance functions. Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) Own the development and ongoing refinement of annual budgets, monthly forecasts, and long-term financial planning. Track and maintain key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure performance against strategic goals. Conduct hands-on analysis of financial performance, with actionable insights to achieve growth and EBITDA targets. Lead investment analysis and decision support—including customer pricing models and full business case development. Demonstrated expertise in labor cost management and margin improvement strategies. Bring experience across multiple ERP platforms; ERP selection and implementation experience is highly preferred. Accounting & Financial Operations Oversee all accounting and finance functions, ensuring accuracy, integrity, and timeliness of financial information. Prepare and deliver comprehensive financial reporting packages, including monthly P&L, balance sheet, cash flow, and covenant compliance. Ensure all financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP and meet internal and external stakeholder requirements. Lead all month-end close activities, including general ledger, balance sheet reconciliations, and overhead allocation. Enhance and scale accounting processes, systems, and internal controls to support company growth. Coordinate the annual audit process, ensuring unqualified audit results. Lead the preparation and management of company-wide budgets, including revenue and capital expenditure planning. Treasury & Working Capital Management Lead cash flow forecasting, management, and decision-making around weekly cash disbursements. Improve the full cash cycle—credit policy, collections, inventory, and payables management. Manage lender relationships and covenant compliance. Use forward-looking cash flow analysis to guide capital structure decisions and working capital strategy. M&A & Private Equity Engagement Collaborate with the leadership team and private equity sponsors on M&A add-on strategies and roll-up execution. Experience or understanding of value creation planning, reporting, and board-level communication. QUALIFICATIONS Bachelor’s degree in Finance, Accounting, Business Administration, or a related discipline; CPA and MBA strongly preferred. Extensive experience in senior financial leadership roles, ideally within a private equity-backed or high-growth manufacturing environment. Deep understanding of financial and operational disciplines, including P&L ownership, balance sheet management, cash flow optimization, and capital allocation. Demonstrated experience in corporate governance, risk management, and regulatory compliance. Proven ability to lead complex negotiations related to financing, vendor agreements, M&A, and commercial terms. Expertise in budgeting, forecasting, financial modeling, and working capital management; prior public accounting experience is a plus. Strong business acumen with the ability to quickly assess new challenges and make sound, data-driven decisions in a dynamic environment. Natural leadership presence with the ability to build trust and credibility across all levels of an organization and with external stakeholders. Resilient under pressure with a disciplined approach to prioritization, execution, and delegation. Exceptional communication skills—both written and verbal—with the ability to clearly articulate financial concepts to non-financial stakeholders. Committed to service excellence, with strong interpersonal skills and a collaborative leadership style. High attention to detail and precision, balanced with the ability to think strategically and see the broader business context. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by Superior Duct Fabrication to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Tom Haley /503.334.1350/ tom@180one.com .
By Greg Togni December 16, 2025
Every winter, the college football coaching carousel becomes one of the most dramatic leadership upheavals in American sports. In 2025, the carousel was particularly volatile. Multiple programs fired coaches earlier than expected, often mid-season, and then rushed into new hires within days. Boosters demanded decisive action; fans amplified pressure, and athletic directors made million-dollar moves under a microscope. For businesses, it’s easy to dismiss this annual churn as entertainment, but the reality is more nuanced. College football programs face the same leadership dilemmas that companies do - underperformance, culture challenges, stakeholder pressure, competitive threats, and the fear of losing momentum. The difference is that football programs confront these forces at hyper-speed - often making major personnel decisions in hours rather than months. This accelerated environment produces lessons, both good and bad, about how organizations respond when leadership is failing. Below are the Do’s and Don’ts businesses can take away from the way college football programs fire their coaches, and why they often rush into the next hire. DON’T: Fire Without a Succession Plan (Even If Pressure Mounts) One consistent theme from the 2025 season: several programs fired coaches with no clear successor in mind. UCLA’s dismissal of DeShaun Foster in just three games into the season was a perfect example. Foster was a high-profile alumnus with strong player relationships, but early losses led to escalating fan frustration and internal concerns about program direction. UCLA acted quickly to fire him, but doing so left the program scrambling for leadership and stability. They eventually hired Bob Chesney, who was a strong cultural fit, but the initial firing created unnecessary turbulence. Businesses often do the same thing. When a leader falters, the pressure to “do something” can eclipse the need for strategic succession. Boards and CEOs sometimes dismiss underperforming executives impulsively, leaving teams directionless and forcing rushed searches. Business takeaway: Before making a firing decision, especially under pressure, ensure you have: a temporary successor a vetted shortlist clarity on what the next leader must bring a transition plan for teams and clients Without this, you’re not solving a problem- you’re compounding it. DO: Define What Success Looks Like Before You Search A core crisis in many football firings is a lack of alignment between expectations and reality. Coaches are often fired not because they’re outright failures, but because the program never clearly defined what success meant. Look at LSU in 2025. Brian Kelly was fired despite a respectable record by national standards, but LSU boosters expected national contention every year. When performance slipped below that mark, the disconnect became untenable. Then, LSU got caught up in some unnecessary drama with misalignment from multiple stakeholders regarding who has hiring and firing authority. No wonder they never solved what “success” looked like. The same thing happens in business when leaders are hired under vague or overly ambitious expectations. If “success” means different things to stakeholders, the hire is set to fail. Business takeaway: Before starting your search: Define expectations concretely Align board and stakeholder vision Codify cultural priorities This ensures you hire for reality - not fantasy. DON’T: Hire in Haste Just to “Win the News Cycle” College football programs care deeply about perception. When a head coach is fired, boosters and fans expect immediate reassurance. That leads to knee-jerk hires where the priority is speed and optics rather than fit. The 2025 carousel saw multiple programs rush hires within days of firing coaches, sometimes skipping broader searches. Penn State was rumored to have engaged in serious discussions with 3 prospects, with all of them negotiating new deals with their current programs, before the Nittany Lions landed on Matt Campbell from Iowa State. Businesses do this too. After a public executive departure, companies sometimes hire quickly just to demonstrate control. But a fast hire that later fails is far more damaging than a slow, deliberate one. Business takeaway: Speed should never outrank strategy. A thoughtful process reassures stakeholders more than a rushed announcement ever will. DO: Learn From the Mistake and Adjust the Next Hire Accordingly Some programs in 2025 demonstrated a valuable principle: the second decision can fix the first, if you learn from it. UCLA’s rehire after firing Foster showed clear reflection. Their initial hire emphasized emotional connection and recruiting upside. But the next move, hiring Bob Chesney, emphasized proven systems, clear identity, and cultural alignment. UCLA changed its criteria and recalibrated its expectations. Similarly, Stanford fired Troy Taylor earlier in the year following concerns about program direction and culture. Their next hire, Tavita Pritchard, was a past member of the Cardinal’s coaching staff known for stability and alignment with Stanford’s academic and philosophical identity. Rather than repeating the same mistake, Stanford course corrected. Businesses often fail here. They fire a leader but then hire someone nearly identical, because the root cause of failure was never clearly articulated. Business takeaway: Post-mortem analysis is essential. Identify: What went wrong What was missing What stakeholders expected but didn’t receive What qualities matter most next time Then hire based on those insights - not simply on instinct. DON’T: Let Stakeholder Noise Dictate Decisions In college football, boosters, fans, media, and donors create a storm of pressure. This noise often accelerates firings or influences hires in unhealthy ways. Businesses face similar noise: activist investors, board factions, client concerns, internal politics, and public perception. Leaders who succumb to noise risk making short-term decisions that hurt long-term stability. Business takeaway: Listen to stakeholders, but don’t let them drive the process. Data, fit, and long-term strategy must guide leadership hiring. DO: Leverage Internal Talent When Stability Matters More Than Splash Amid the chaos of 2025, some programs opted for internal stability rather than external splash. While many schools chased headline-grabbing hires, others elevated coordinators and internal staff who already had trust equity with players. These transitions, including schools that promoted assistants after mid-season firings, created continuity in an environment where change was everywhere. Business takeaway: The flashy external hire is not always the right one. Internal candidates often bring: Quicker adaptation Stronger cultural alignment Built-in trust Reduced onboarding risk Especially after a turbulent departure, stability can be more valuable than novelty. DON’T: Underestimate the Ripple Effects of Leadership Turnover Firing in college football isn’t isolated. It affects: Recruiting Donor confidence Locker room morale Staff retention Public perception The same is true in business. Leadership changes impact: Client relationships Employee engagement Brand reputation Productivity Strategic continuity Business takeaway: Programs that manage these effects proactively, communicate openly, support interim leaders, and maintain messaging discipline reduce fallout. Businesses need to treat leadership transitions as enterprise-level events, not HR procedures. The 2025 college football season demonstrated how high-pressure environments reveal the strengths and flaws of leadership decision-making. Businesses can learn from both the impulsive mistakes and intentional successes that football programs showed this year. If businesses apply these lessons, they’ll avoid the chaos of the coaching carousel, while benefiting from the clarity it provides about leadership, culture, and long-term success.
By Effie Zimmerman December 11, 2025
Vice President of Operations ABOUT THE COMPANY Founded in 1993 in Portland, Oregon, Pavement Maintenance Inc. (PMI) specializes in sealcoating, striping, pavement and concrete repair, and parking lot sweeping for leading property managers and facility owners throughout the region with its dedicated team of 100 employees. The company serves a diverse customer base across commercial, industrial, multifamily, retail, and healthcare properties, focused on recurring maintenance work and long-term customer relationships. With PMI’s acquisition of Vancouver Paving, its service offering expanded into all phases of paving, from minor repairs to new construction. In 2025, PMI joined Trinity Hunt Partners’ newly created paving services platform company Sage Surface Partners (“Sage”). Sage will be represented in the market with other best-in-class commercial paving services companies that share a strong commitment to quality, service, and their people. THE ROLE Reporting directly to the President of PMI, the Vice President (VP) of Operations will be a key member of the executive team, responsible for transforming and scaling the operational foundation of a small but growing pavement maintenance and repair company. This leader will combine strategic thinking with a hands-on, roll-up-your-sleeves approach to build systems, processes, and teams capable of supporting organizational growth. The VP of Operations will oversee field operations, project management, quality, safety, fleet/equipment, scheduling/dispatch, and customer satisfaction, driving operational discipline while preserving the agile, service-driven culture that has led to their market-leading position. RESPONSIBILITIES Operational Leadership & Scaling Build and mature operational infrastructure, including SOPs, workflows, and performance metrics, to support PMI growth targets. Provide day-to-day leadership of field and operations teams, ensuring high-quality and efficient delivery of our suite of pavement maintenance and paving services. Develop and implement initiatives such as business process modernization, cost optimization, and expansion readiness. People Leadership & Culture Development Model strong leadership behaviors, including clear communication, follow-through, integrity, and a commitment to developing others. Mentor and coach field leadership teams, helping them grow in decision-making, planning, and leadership capability. Promote a culture of ownership and engagement by empowering team members, recognizing strong performance, and fostering constructive problem-solving. Lead through change, helping employees understand the ‘why’ behind new systems, expectations, and processes that will support company growth. Project & Production Management Oversee scheduling, dispatching, crew planning, and resource allocation to ensure projects are delivered on time, within budget, and to quality standards. Introduce or refine project management tools and job costing practices to improve visibility and accuracy of operational performance. Identify bottlenecks and implement solutions that drive productivity and increase capacity. Safety, Compliance & Risk Management Strengthen the company’s safety culture through training, compliance monitoring, and the consistent application of best practices. Ensure adherence to OSHA, DOT, and other regulatory requirements across field operations. Establish scalable safety programs that can support future growth into additional markets. Fleet, Equipment & Materials Oversight Oversee procurement, maintenance, utilization, and lifecycle management of heavy equipment and materials. Streamline maintenance processes, ensure proper tracking systems are in place, and reduce downtime. Evaluate opportunities for capital investment to support efficiency and capacity improvements. Quality Assurance & Customer Experience Foster a customer-first mindset, ensuring work quality, communication, and responsiveness meet or exceed expectations. Handle escalated issues professionally, preserving customer relationships during a period of company transition and growth. Collaborate closely with sales and estimating teams to align operational delivery with customer commitments. Financial Stewardship & Strategic Execution Develop and manage operational budgets, forecasting production needs, staffing levels, equipment costs, and overtime management. Partner with the President and organizational leaders on reporting, KPI tracking, and operational improvement priorities. Provide insights and recommendations to leadership on growth opportunities, market expansion, and operational investments. QUALIFICATIONS Bachelor’s degree in Construction Management, Engineering, Business Administration, or related field preferred; equivalent experience considered. 7–10+ years of progressive leadership experience in construction or related service industries, or pavement maintenance operations. Experience working in a small-business environment, preferably during a phase of ownership transition or private-equity involvement. Strong background in building processes, implementing systems, and driving organizational maturity. Excellent leadership and communication skills, with the ability to motivate teams through change and rapid growth. Demonstrated expertise in scheduling, job costing, production management, and safety. Ability to be both strategic and hands-on—comfortable working in the field, in the office, and with investors. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by PMI to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Nicole Brady at 180one at 503.699.0184 / nicole@180one.com .
More Posts